Gold-toned Printing-out Prints

Edward S. Curtis, Unpublished Lishhaiahit - Kittitas (Leschi)
Artist: Edward S. Curtis (1868-1952)
Title: “Unpublished Lishhaiahit – Kittitas (Leschi)”
Medium: Gold-toned Printing-out Print
Size: 14 1/4 x 11 1/4 inches | Framed: 29 x 25 inches
Original Curtis frame.
Negative #12
Signed: L.L.

Gold-toned Printing-out prints (more commonly known as albumen prints) are Curtis’ earliest and scarcest master exhibition prints. This handful of exquisite prints was printed in or proximal to 1900, when Curtis made his watershed journey to the Montana Plains to witness one of the final Piegan Sundances.

It is likely Curtis printed these images himself, in sunlight, while on that expedition. No other photographs are as close to Curtis’ own hands. It is believed there are less than 70 surviving examples of this process. Printing-out prints are the most coveted and important photographs Curtis produced. Artist: Edward S. Curtis (1868-1952)

Edward S. Curtis, Homeward (Puget Sound)
Artist: Edward S. Curtis (1868-1952)
Title: “Homeward” (Puget Sound)
Medium: Gold-Toned Printing-out Print
Size: 5 5/8 x 7.81 inches | Framed: 16 x 20 inches
Signed L.L

Curtis never printed on an albumen paper. We have termed them albumen because the medium has technically been mislabeled. We simply use “albumen” for simplicity and consistency.

The early Curtis prints we call “albumen” are actually gelatin printing out prints. The process is the same for both albumen and gelatin printing out prints. The sensitized paper was placed in direct contact with a glass negative and exposed in strong light-usually sunlight. Then, the image formed on the paper while in contact with the negative and during its exposure to light. The final image was then toned with gold for color and permanence.

Edward S. Curtis, Unpublished Lishhaiahit - Kittitas (Leschi)
Artist: Edward S. Curtis (1868-1952)
Title: “Unpublished Lishhaiahit – Kittitas (Leschi)”
Medium: Gold-toned Printing-out Print
Size: 7 x 5 1/4 inches | Framed: 16 x 13 1/4 inches
Frame is a vintage period frame.
Signed: L.L.

The difference between albumen and gelatin printing-out prints is in the papers. In both cases, a thin layer of emulsion sits above the paper and contains the light-sensitive silver salts which react with light to form the image. In albumen prints, that emulsion is made from whisked egg whites, and therefore called albumen. In gelatin printing out prints, the emulsion is made from gelatin, which is a starch.  Gelatin prints are more stable than albumen prints because albumen decays very easily in the presence of moisture and light.

 

Geronimo: A Visual Comparison of Edward Curtis and Andy Warhol’s Representation of the Figure

With a legacy half rooted in myth, it is of no surprise that the Chiricahua Apache leader Geronimo caught the eyes of both Edward Curtis and Andy Warhol, two esteemed artists in their own right. Geronimo was born near the Gila River headwaters in New Mexico and became a warrior after his mother, wife, and three children were killed in a raid by Mexican soldiers in 1858. The legend goes that the vengeful Geronimo could make himself invisible in battle and defy bullets, injury, and capture. However, the Apache warrior surrendered in 1886, marking the formal end of organized military resistance by Native Americans to their conquerors.

Edward Curtis had the privilege of meeting Geronimo in 1905 when they were both invited to attend President Theodore Roosevelt’s inauguration. Despite Geronimo’s status as a prisoner of war and only being able to leave Fort Still with government permission, the fire had not left the 76-year-old Apache warrior’s eyes. Infatuated with Geronimo’s resilience while simultaneously outraged by his forced assimilation, Curtis resolved to transmit the truth of this hardened man through his camera.  After persuading Geronimo to pose for a separate sitting Curtis wrote, “the spirit of the Apache is not broken.”

In Curtis’ 1905 photograph, Geronimo is captured in profile and caught in a moment of retrospection. He is wearing only a cloth headband (as he wore in his youth) and a rough woolen blanket that envelops his entire upper body. The lack of ornamentation and formal regalia paints the famous icon in a rather modest light and creates a solemn mood as the viewer reflects alongside Geronimo. The plain background and simple garb also serve to draw attention to Geronimo’s own character. Even with only half his face visible, the viewer can easily identify Geronimo’s defiant and prideful attitude in subtleties such as his pressed lips, clenched jaw, and furrowed brow. The deep lines of his face tell the story of his life and his refusal to give up nothing for sympathy.

Alternatively, Andy Warhol’s 1986 “Geronimo” from his Cowboys and Indians series is a screen print based on an 1887 photograph by A. Frank Randall. In the original photo, Geronimo is kneeling holding a rifle surrounded by southwestern shrubbery; yet, in truth, Geronimo had already surrendered and been captured as a prisoner of war at the time this photo was taken. Warhol uses this image but crops it to reveal only Geronimo’s face. Similar to Curtis’ rendition, this close-up emphasizes Geronimo’s own identity. In this portrayal, the viewer faces the full force of Geronimo’s direct glare. Gestural lines only accentuate his strong facial features and angered expression. Warhol’s print is also rendered in bold and vibrant colors, a fiery red, yellow, and deep purple made imposing by the little negative space. The use of bright hues is emblematic of Warhol’s Pop Art style and transforms the historical figure into a celebrity icon. This romanticized view of the American West mirrors that of the public and evokes issues of exploitation, conflict, and historical representation.

While both artists successfully capture Geronimo’s spirit in their artwork, they employ entirely different means. Edward Curtis’ “Geronimo” yields a more introspective effect, whereas Warhol intentionally commodifies Geronimo. However, it is evident in viewing these pieces that both Curtis and Warhol shared a fascination and deep appreciation for this tough and proud Apache Leader.

Both “Geronimo” pieces are available now at Valley Fine Art. Please contact info@valleyfineart.com for further information.

Press Release- VFA Presents Andrew Bolam, Cutting-edge American Wildlife Painter

VFA Presents Andrew Bolam, Cutting-edge American Wildlife Painter

Artist’s Reception to be held at the gallery on August 21 from 5 to 9 pm

Andrew Bolam is a contemporary wildlife painter whose star has risen exponentially in recent years. Far from an overnight sensation, Bolam’s artistic portfolio reveals that since the ’90s he has produced continually important work. This August, Valley Fine Art will offer many of his large pieces for sale.

The artist pulls from an internal wellspring of spontaneity and joy, and he comes to his studio with no other buyer in mind but himself. Bolam explains, I don’t paint for anyone else, I paint for myself,” he says, adding that he asks himself, What would I like to hang on my walls if I had a giant house with giant walls for canvas? Bolam insists that when an artist stays true to himself or herself, a consumer will walk into the gallery and spot the authentic piece every time. This level of authenticity has been his ticket to success.

Having been on Valley Fine Art’s hit list of featured artists since 2016, Bolam will enjoy the sole spotlight on August 21, 2021. The opening reception will be from 5 to 9 pm in the Gallery. Buyers and art lovers are invited to view paintings like “Piqued,” “Sensitive,” and “Job,” among eight others offered for sale. “Andrew’s pieces play with people’s perspective of what they’re seeing. He challenges your idea of what contemporary wildlife art should be,” says Mia Valley.

Andrew Bolam was singled out in his early teenage years as a rare talent in his region of northern England. The grandson of a coal miner and son of a bus driver, Bolam did not personally know any artists, but he knew he had a gift and the hunger to pursue painting.  He moved to the U.S. and found his muse in western creatures and culture. In 2000, he opened a studio and gallery in California. “I promised myself that I didn’t have to make a lot of money, but I had to keep painting my way, and as long as I could afford food, I’d keep going.” The painter is seeing the fruits of his labor. Decades of continued excellence in his craft have yielded recognition and sales.

Bolam’s paintings defy categorization. Every year he introduces a series of paintings, the idea for which germinates in his mind for months. To represent each series’ idea, Bolam explains, “I go into my toolbag and choose the resource that best expresses the idea,” selecting among different substrates like canvas, panels, or paper, and using either oils, acrylics, watercolors, gouache, or crayons. “I don’t want to limit myself to one style, I think artists have ideas, and the end result should be in service to that idea,” Bolam says.

His pieces sing with authenticity. That voice you hear when you stand before “Piqued”—it’s Bolam’s invitation to question what you’re seeing: “Come up close,” he recommends, “look at the way the knife lays the paint on the canvas. See the drips of paint and the deliberately left runs. Notice the surface quality of the piece. Now step away and notice that the very simplified shapes and marks on the canvas build like puzzle pieces from an abstract idea into a representational image.”

Using his alchemy of texture, abstraction, and design, Bolam ensures that every square inch of the canvas is visually interesting. He believes that good art leaves something for the viewer to do; good art asks questions like What’s happening with the alignment here? Why the thick paint here in this quadrant? Why has the artist made these decisions? By then, he’s got you. You’re in conversation with the art and having a feeling. Which is, after all, the point.

About The Gallery

Situated in the heart of downtown Aspen at the historic Wheeler Opera House (behind the scaffolding), Valley Fine Art is open to browsers and collectors alike. Come enjoy our happy atmosphere and chat with our knowledgeable staff.

###

For further information, please contact Mia Valley of Valley Fine Art.

 

Peace Medals

If you’re familiar with Edward Curtis’ project, “The North American Indian”, you may have seen vintage photographs of Native Americans wearing medals and adornments around their neck. Have you ever wondered about the significance of such metals? There is still some controversy over the use and impact of ‘peace metals’ in furthering diplomatic relationships between Native Americans and the federal government. We’re here to tell you more.

Indian Peace Medals refer to the ovular or circular medals awarded to tribal leaders throughout colonial America and early United States history. These medals were usually made of silver or brass, ranging in size from about one to six inches. Peace medals were issued to build alliances and negotiate with tribes. This has been done as early as the seventeenth century. For Native Americans, these medals represented a pledge to supply and trade commodities. They would provide raw materials like animal hides, furs, and feathers, and in return, get kettles, beads, ornaments, clothes, and weapons.

Peace Medals were more than just a symbol of happy trade. They were an expression of America’s promise of being invested to furthering the peace and diplomacy with the Indians who called this land home.

Also, the awarding of Peace Medals often meant there was a formal treaty or negotiation in place. The ultimate origin of Indian Peace Medals is not entirely known, however Thomas Jefferson noted that the usage of the medals is “an ancient custom.”

In addition to Peace Medals, Presidential Medals were also gifted. The distribution of presidential medals accompanied nearly every formal interaction between Native Americans and the U.S. federal government. Lewis and Clark distributed about eighty-seven peace medals to Indian leaders as a demonstration of goodwill under Jefferson’s name. The medals were only given to “influential persons,” with the largest of medals reserved for Indian chiefs and warriors.

It was a great honor to receive a medal and the Native Americans associated great value with the acceptance of one. They were to be buried with the pedals remaining around their neck. The considerable amount of portraiture of Native American figures accentuating the medals around their neck serves as a testament to their importance. The medals became a physical representation of a spiritual dimension that linked the wearer to a source of power, for example, the “Great Father” as President Washington was referred to by the recipients. The distribution of peace and presidential medals reinforced and furthered a political order within the tribes.

Ceremonial Dances of Native American Tribes

Atsina

This tribe conducted five ceremonies that were of distinct religious character. A very influential portion of them were intended to amuse as well, and they differed greatly by theme, but were very similar in their initiation and delegation. These ceremonies were executed by a member of one of the companies. “While all men whose age lay between certain limits had the right to perform the ceremony appropriate to that age, they were organized, not in one company, but in several, each one of which gave the ceremony without the assistance of any of the others; and a company had the right to perform the same ceremony more than once.”

A man would feel a vow to perform a ceremony in return for the recovery of a loved one from illness, or the preservation of his life in the midst of peril. This man would select an elder man who would have charge of the ceremony. Then, each man of the company would select an elder man, to be known as his “Grandfather.” The Grandfathers would paint the dancers and the dancers’ wives, and every night they would leave camp to observe certain rites by which the old men rendered their medicine to the dancers.

The Fly Dance

In the dance of the Fly Society which lasted one day, the performers were made up of four tiers. There were leaders, the pledger, four “elder brothers,” who were members of companies that already gave the Fly Dance, and finally, the rank and file of members. They were identified by different garments and body paint.

The Grandfathers were to chew an herb which would make the dancers brave and strong as it was rubbed all over them. Around noon, the members of the society assembled in their lodge and filed out, making circular movements around the encampment. They would start to dance, holding their robes outstretched, in a wing fashion, and made humming noises as if they were mosquitoes. At the close of the dance, the dancers all fell to their knees in a circle, and bowed their head to the ground. When the dance ended, the Flies were free to spend the next two hours pursuing all bystanders by poking them with their long sticks with a cactus prick at the end. After this, they gathered in the center of camp and ran four races, then shifted to a time of feasting on meat, which one of their company’s members had prepared.

The Crazy Dance

If a man vowed to conduct the Crazy Dance, he took a pipe to an old man who was familiar with its performance. If the old man accepted the pipe, he became the “Maker of the Crazy Dance.” The members of the company chose Grandfathers to them as they did with the Fly Dance. In this dance, every member of the company was expected to participate.

They were dressed in robes with holes cut near the top where their head came through, like a poncho. There were two loose strips of the robe that hung down from their shoulders which ended in feathers and claws of an owl. They were painted yellow to the knees and elbows. They carried bows and arrows to which crow feathers were attached, and whistles made of eagle wing-bones. On their head, one side was covered with clay, the ears stuffed full with a spongy fungus, and an owl head was worn off the right temple. They carried four-foot staffs, and hung from them were hoofs and claws of various animals.

The ceremony lasted four days and four nights. The dancing continued until darkness, when the dancers’ wives followed the Grandfathers beyond the camp circle to receive medicine from them. As they returned to the lodge, they were kissed by all the dancers, and the wives’ husband would then kiss the Grandfather.

In the mornings, everyone gathered in the lodge. The dancers’ wives took their places behind the Grandfathers and the dancers marched around the lodge, then stopped until the singers commenced. The dancing went on all day, and each time the singing began, the principal Grandfather arose, and then all others joined. On the fourth day there was a fire kindled in the center of the lodge. Grandfather would say “it is time for the Crazy men to dance in the fire.” This meant the dancers must dance on the glowing embers of the blazing fire. They all leaped on the coals until every ember was extinguished. Following that, all the dancers ran outside to discharge their arrows straight up into the sky above them. Each one stood their motionless, in bravery, among the falling shafts.

The Crazy men were free to play pranks and do mischievous actions until nightfall. They would go around shooting people with blunt arrows, saying the opposite of what they meant, and doing the opposite of what they were told. For others, the only refuge one could seek was behind one of the Grandfathers. The ceremony ended on the fourth day as darkness fell upon the tribe.

The Dance of the Fox Society

Following this dance was always the removal of the camp to a new location. As like other dances, it was initiated by the man who had promised its performance. He would seek the help of an old man, and each man of the company would select a Grandfather. This dance, much like the Crazy Dance, lasted four days and four nights, with the dancing taking place during the daytime. Four members of each company carried around a seven foot staff, bent like a shepherd’s crook. These men were of known bravery and were supposed to never leave the grounds in which they planted their standards.

A chosen virgin was chosen to represent the Fox Mother, who’s supposed children were the dancers. The members of the dance entered the lodge and seated themselves in two rows, one on each side of the lodge. A staff-bearer sat at each end of the row, and the Fox Mother was seated behind the dancers who formed the end of the southern row. The man who initiated the dance slept between the two rows near the door. The dancers danced in a circle and moved to the left while the Fox Mother danced in the opposite direction around the perimeter of the circle.

On the last night, relatives of the members of the company brought gifts to the Grandfathers. Early the next morning, the encampment would move to new grounds. Before reaching the new campsite, they halted about halfway when the dancers gained some distance on the gifts which had been received. The warriors charged upon the heap of gifts, selecting from it an article similar to something he had captured in battle.

The Dance of Dog Society

The principal features of this dance resembled the ceremonies of the other societies. In this ceremony, there were two leaders, one wearing a red shirt, and the other yellow, both lined with crow feathers. The other members wore a red cloth over one shoulder and under the other, with the end trailing on the ground. Their robes, and them, were fixed by a staff which was thrust into the ground. The warrior was not permitted to move until someone, a non-member, drove him away, speaking to the member as if he were a dog.

Each Dog Dancer carried eagle-bone whistles and small wands made of deer hoofs, and they all wore eagle feather headdresses. The dance lasted for four days and took place in a large lodge.

The Dance of Drum Society

This ceremony was performed by the bravest men, which were the most experienced warriors in the tribe. This ceremony also lasted four days and four nights. There were four leaders who had crooked staffs wrapped with sacred white buffalo skin. All were painted red and white with dots representing hail and with zigzag lines for lightning. They wore only a loin cloth. “They possessed a drum which, if the dance had been performed a short time before, they might in battle throw towards the enemy. The members then ran to it and stood there fighting, until either the enemy gave way or they themselves were killed.”

Edward Sheriff Curtis’ work is more important than Vincent Van Gogh

There are many parallels in the lives of Vincent Van Gogh and Edward Sheriff Curtis.

  • Both men died practically unknown and penniless, but their work was saved by family.
  • Both displayed genius in their craft, pursued it with passion and continued against crushing psychological odds.
  • Both had a view of the world far greater than was appreciated in their time, only to be widely recognized as significantly important artists, after they were gone.

As with many before, their genius was not understood in their time. Van Gogh painted the dynamics of physics in the energy of his brush strokes, and Curtis captured what others dismissed and denigrated when he recognized the import of documenting a “vanishing race”.

Not just an American history, but a contribution to world history, in understanding an indigent people.

A collector of Edward S Curtis is a steward of great art.

Recognize the command Curtis had over artistic elements brought to the work!

His intentional study of photography made him a cutting-edge and recognized pictorial documenter, with a developed eye for creating compositionally balanced photographs. Attention to lighting detail is expressed in his studio work with subjects engaged in such a way as to expose an interesting portrait.

In the larger scale of his new endeavor and environment he was able to translate an extension of the studio talent onto wide-open spaces with uncooperative aspects of nature. His intuition and psychological awareness to create connection with his Indian subjects, who selectively allowed him to capture cultural character, engaged them in the story to reveal their culture and proud heritage with visual interest.

A collector of Edward S Curtis is a steward of critically important history.

As for Edward S Curtis’ personal historical significance – Thirty years creating the largest ethnographic documentation in The North American Indian has historically and artistically invaluable importance.

From the inception of his work, his story captures excursions to Alaska, meetings with financial tycoons, royalty, early cinematic and audio dabbling, and the never-ending marketing genius to raise capital for a nineteenth century start-up. The value of knowing the right people shows up with the influence of a Famous American Explorer and an American President, both of whom recognized his talent for preserving natural beauty. Their admiration translated into encouragement of a young photographer; who would spend thirty years sacrificing family, fortune and comfort; for the recording of The North American Indian.

A visionary of marketing, Edward Curtis created a subscription method. Over the thirty years, Edward financed his work from 290 sets of 20 portfolios and accompanying written history volumes. Subscribers included King George V of England, Andrew Carnegie, J. P. Morgan, Princeton University. MIA – Add a few more recognizable people here.

An Opportunity to become a steward and collector of History and Art:

Valley Fine Art in Aspen, Colorado has an opportunity for you, as collector.

A recent acquisition includes 7 intact and in excellent condition Volumes of written and pictorial history. This unusual find contains the portraits, landscape and recorded cultural lifestyle of Northern Plains Indian tribes.

Upon its completion in 1930, the work, entitled “The North American Indian”, consisted of 20 volumes, containing 1172 hand-pressed photogravures and 4000 pages of written text.  Each volume was accompanied by a corresponding portfolio containing at least 36 large photogravures in each portfolio, 722 in total.

Available:

Complete Volume VI – Piegan, Cheyenne, Arapaho

Paper type: Dutch Van Gelder
Year: 1908

 

Complete Volume VII – Yakima, Klickitat, Salishan tribe of the interior, Kutenai

Paper type: Dutch Van Gelder

Year: 1910

 

Complete Volume VIII – Nez Perce, Wallawalla, Umatilla, Cayuse, Chinookan tribes.

Paper type: Dutch Van Gelder

Year: 1910

 

Complete Volume X – The Kwakiutl

Paper type: Dutch Van Gelder

Date: 1914

Provenance: Subscription #456, Original Subscriber: Art Institute of Chicago

Complete Volume XI – Nootka and Haida

Paper type: Dutch Van Gelder

Date: 1915

Provenance: Subscription #57

Complete Volume XII – Hopi

Paper type: Dutch Van Gelder

Date: 1922

 

Complete Volume XVIII –  Chipewyan, Cree and Sarsi

Paper type: Dutch Van Gelder

Provenance: Subscription #456: Art Institute of Chicago

A Facelift for Le Grande Dame of Aspen and the Entrance to Valley Fine Art 

A Facelift for Le Grande Dame of Aspen and the Entrance to Valley Fine Art 

Let’s face it, any Grande Dame who is 131 years old may need some work done. Her resplendent interior, with glowing wood textures and royal hues, was marvelously remodeled in 2015/2016 and updated with modern conveniences and a rejuvenated historicity. And now it’s time to help the old lady with her mountain-weathered exterior. 

Our home, The Wheeler Opera House, has occupied the corner of Mill and Hyman since its opening in 1889, and survived a fire in 1921. The stonework is amazingly intact, and still expresses the craftsmanship of those 19th century builders’ ability to stack stone on stone for 3 stories without compromising their integrity in physics. 

But nothing is perfect and gravity will pull at any weaknesses in construction, creating the need for shoring up, replacing or polishing the wear and tear. 

Current events that have prompted the closure of the Wheeler Opera House are also providing a perfect opportunity to complete scheduled work, on the stonework, in a much shorter time frame than was originally scheduled. For a few months, likely to be September 15 through November, the façade will be screened from view with scaffolding, debris netting and printed banner wraps while the contractor replaces compromised pieces with custom-fitted stones.

We feel honored to have our home in such an important piece of Aspen History, where culture and the arts are continually celebrated, where comedy and music bring laughter and lift spirits and where we enjoy watching as patrons stroll by, stopping in to spend time with us and our extraordinary artists. 

Like the Wheeler, it was in the 1880’s that Edward S Curtis, our premier historian and photographer of the North American Indians, was encouraged by President Theodore Roosevelt, and underwritten by J. P. Morgan a fellow tycoon to the builder of the opera house, Jerome B. Wheeler. While you spend your entertainment time online, please enjoy the following:

Shadow Catcher – This documentary is about the historically important work and journey of Edward Sheriff Curtis: https://youtu.be/ZhNNmo2Si-o

The Valley Fine Art website has our current inventory and a biography for the artist (link: https://www.valleyfineart.com/edward-curtis-photos-for-sale/#inventory

While we wait with anticipation for the reveal of the finished stone restoration project, Valley Fine Art will remain flexible to the progress as to if we will be open. We will always be available for appointments: 970-920-9193, or call for any questions.

8 Details You Should Know About Valley Fine Art’s Rare and Vintage Mining Claim Maps of Aspen

 

These rare maps, photographs, and documents will take you on a visual tour through Aspen in the late 1880s. Give your house a sense of place with a beautiful map or hand-drawn survey.

  • One important, original drawing from 1891 is “Town Site of Aspen,” from the estate of John H. Marks, which shows all the original buildings in Aspen.
  • This collection is the result of decades of careful selection by gallery owner and born-and-raised Aspenite, Mia Valley.
  • Colorado had been a state for only three years when Aspen was established as a mining camp, one of the most remote in Colorado, in June 1879.
  • The Gallery acquired these historical documents from the estate of John H. Marks, who was a U.S. Deputy Mineral Surveyor in Aspen during the mining boom.
  • One remarkable map is a unique drawing dated 1891 measuring a staggering fifteen feet long! This detailed survey documents every building of the town site of Aspen all the way down to Woody Creek. It also traces the railroad’s path through the valley and the brisk, enduring Roaring Fork river.
  • History and art lovers would both love, “A Matched Set of Maps of the Mining Claims North and South of Aspen.” These vintage maps show the entire town as well as the backside of Aspen Mountain, which many locals know as Little Annie Basin. Maps such as these would have been displayed in a mining office.
  • Valley Fine Art has for sale the colorful, hand-drawn survey “Ranches of the Roaring Fork Valley,” which features the coordinates of town, the surrounding rivers, and likely showing ownership of various placers (claims) downvalley.
  • The maps show the routes of the railroads. Railroads were an intraoral part of the mining industry, and a key element when looking to add a vintage map to a collection.

These are 8 great reasons to come to Valley Fine Art to observe these spectacular maps. Now is your chance to seize the rare opportunity to own a piece of Aspen’s wild west history.

 

 

NOTES FROM “THE NORTH AMERICAN INDIAN”

NOTES FROM “THE NORTH AMERICAN INDIAN”

BY EDAWRD S. CURTIS

VOLUME VI – NOTES ON INDIAN MUSIC

“In the course of transcribing Indian melodies from phonographic cylinders for Volumes VI, VII, and VIII, one of the first things to impress me was the impossibility of representing these melodies accurately by means of our normal musical notation. The principal reason for this difficulty is that while our notation provides for the representation of certain definite degrees of pitch (and those only), the Indian habitually sings degrees of pitch for which we have no symbols. For instance, we can represent e (330 vibrations per second) and f (352 vibrations per second), but when an Indian sings a tone lying somewhere between these two (say 335 vibrations per second), our notation is powerless to represent this tone with accuracy.

In such cases I have written the note which most nearly approximated the tone sung by the Indian. A notation could easily have been invented which would have permitted the more accurate expression of Indian melody, but this would have been of questionable value. If the Indian deliberately uses a different scheme of tones and intervals from that of the civilized races, as had been suggested, one would naturally expect this difference to stand out clearly, or at least noticeably, in the course of several repetitions of the same song. But in the examination of more than sixty songs much variation appears in the repetitions of each one. As a general rule the repetitions fail to agree in length, rhythm, or accuracy of intonation; frequently they agree only in general contour. It can truthfully be said that in the case of the phonographic records examined by me for these three volumes no song is repeated twice exactly alike. Any single tone is likely to vary up or down at least a quarter of a tone, and in some cases the variation is as much as a full tone. It is more than likely that the Indian is somewhat blindly groping for the diatonic intervals which form the basis of civilized music, and that his deviations there from are not caused by a conscious disregard of them so much as by his inability to intone them accurately. In many instances, however, he is quite successful in his use of the usual diatonic intervals, and while he vary rarely uses the complete diatonic scale, he frequently uses five or even six of the tones comprising it.

But there is a great difference in his manner of using these tones from that of civilized man. In the melody of civilized man the tones are all related to a central tone called the tonic or key-tone, and however widely they may wander from this key-note, a definite relationship to it is always preserved, the melody usually ending on the key-note itself. This relationship among the tones of the melody produces a definite musical atmosphere called a tonality or key. Among the Indians this sense of tonality is largely lacking. In the majority of songs no key is established which lasts throughout the song. Here and there a few measures definitely indicate a particular key, but the sense of this key is usually lost before the song ends. In many of the songs no key whatever, as we understand it, is established, such songs being more or less rhythmic yells upon certain tones, and sounding much as if they were intended for incantations rather than songs. An occasional song is found, however, in which the sense of tonality is quite perfect.

Although rhythm is of great importance to the Indian, it is my belief that he has not consciously developed any very complicated rhythmic schemes. All the rhythmic schemes which have come under my observation seem to be very simple and the complexities which have arisen seem to me to be purely accidental. When a song is accompanied by a drum-beat, it usually happens that the drummer keeps time in the most rigid and inflexible manner throughout the song. The singer, on the contrary, will introduce ritards, accelerandos, pauses of different lengths, and numerous variations of time. There consequently arise many complicated rhythmic relationships between the drum-beat and the melody. But inasmuch as both singer and drummer start with evident agreement as regards time and accent, it is quite probable that the subsequent complications are accidental rather than intentional.

The Indian’s manner of singing has much to do with the particular character of his music. Embellishments such as grace-notes, trills, and shakes abound. Pure sustained tones are somewhat rare. Most long tones are broken up by a kind of fluttering or pulsing of the voice. In most instances this has been carefully indicated in the transcriptions. The Indian is also addicted to the exaggerated use of portamento, or the slurring of one tone into another. Instead of singing one definite tone after another, he is very apt to glide from one tone to the next, producing the impression that he is feeling his way among the intervals. This has been indicated in the most marked cases by the sign \ and in other cases, where it is not so apparent by the slur. Extended slurs have also been used to indicate phrasing, as is the custom in civilized music.

The Indian singer also takes many liberties with the time. Although rhythmic values are fairly well preserved, he introduces retards and accelerandos, and sometimes a long ritenuto, causing the end of the song to be sung at a much slower rate than the beginning. On the other hand songs that accompany dancing or other regular rhythmic movements are sung in strict time.

It is impossible, especially while listening to those Indian melodies of which the tonality is more or less perfect, to escape the conviction that the primitive music has been considerably influenced by the Indian’s contact with the white man. In Nature melody is represented by the songs of the birds, the sighing of the wind in the forest, the babbling of mountain brooks, and there is no doubt that the Indian in his first attempts at melody was largely influenced by such sounds. But with the coming of white men a new musical element was brought to him; the element of tonality. Tonality is present in even the simplest folk-song sung by the rudest pioneer, and it is but natural that the Indian should imitate the songs of the pioneers just as he had imitated the sounds of Nature. It is well known with what patience and perseverance the early Jesuit missionaries taught the Indians to sing church hymns, and when one listens to such (Indian) songs, it seems certain that the Indian music of the present day shows this influence.

By no means the least interesting feature of an Indian song is the yell which precedes so many of them. This yell is usually a very complicated affair, and besides mere shouting is apt to consist of trills, shakes, slurs, and frequently short but quite well-defined musical phrases. When a musical phrase is hinted at in a yell, the same phrase is usually to be found in much more developed form in the subsequent song. This is to be expected, as the yell is simply a wild prelude to the song, a tuning up of the voice, the singer getting himself into the mood, as it were. Of course, the yells practically defy accurate expression in musical notation. At first hearing they sound decidedly more akin to noise than music. The voice glides with such rapidity and in such a slurring and sliding manner through so many changes of pitch that often only the approximate contour of melodic outline of the yell can be indicated. I nevertheless consider these yells to be more interesting, and certainly more significant from an ethnological point of view, than many of the melodies themselves.

Songs are frequently followed by yells, but these are not musically important, as they consist for the greatest part of one or two shouts with a with a falling inflection of the voice, and have no relation to the foregoing song. Sometimes, however, the yell at the end consists of a long and beautifully sustained tones at the top of the voice.

Transcribing Indian melodies in ordinary musical notation is somewhat like forcing a square peg into a round hole; it can be accomplished by dint of sufficient exertion, but the original form may have suffered. The vital part of these melodies can be expressed on our notation, but many a delicate nuance of wild and wayward beauty will have disappeared. However, though the letter may be bruised in the process, enough of the spirit survives to make the transcription valuable, but not only to the reader of today, but especially to the student of the future, who will find in such records as these his only opportunity to study this phase of primitive culture. It is in the songs of a people that we rightly look for the greatest spontaneity of self-expression.”

HENRY F. GILBERT

See attached image of “Love Songs”. See more music in this volume: http://curtis.library.northwestern.edu/curtis/viewPage.cgi?showp=1&size=2&id=nai.06.book.00000246&volume=6#nav

Valley Fine Art Hosts Reception to Benefit the Curtis Legacy Foundation

Valley Fine Art Hosts Reception to Benefit the Curtis Legacy Foundation
Opening reception February 14 & 15 from 5 to 9pm at the gallery

Aspen is home to the most thorough collection of Edward S. Curtis photographs in the West. This unique and rare collection is a draw for collectors and historians alike. Mark your calendars for February 14 and 15 at 5 pm, when Valley Fine Art will host Edward S. Curtis’s great grandson, John Graybill, and raise funds to support his foundation, the Curtis Legacy Foundation.

The Curtis Legacy Foundation
John Graybill is undertaking a similar journey as his ancestor, this time focusing his influential camera lens on the living descendants of those North American Indians that Curtis immortalized with his photogravures long ago. The northstar of the Curtis Legacy Foundation to honor the legacy of his great-grandfather with good works for the Native American population.
The foundation’s first major project is to locate, photograph, and interview living descendants of those Indians portrayed in The North American Indian. In 2018, John and his wife Coleen, who is also an accomplished photographer, began this work in Seattle when they photographed Mary Lou Slaughter, the 3x great-granddaughter of Princess Angeline, who was Curtis’ first Native American subject.

Highlights of the Descendants Project so far:
Nine descendants have been interviewed and photographed to date.
Seven tribal nations are currently represented.
One person, now 95 years old, from Curtis’ original photographs has been photographed, with two more located.
One current Chief has participated.
One is a survivor of Indian Residential School.
One, who once shunned her heritage, is now a master basket weaver.
Some actively practice their cultural ceremonies, some do not.
More information about the Descendants Project and the Curtis Legacy Foundation can be found at www.CurtisLegacyFoundation.org.

About the Reception
We are honored to host Edward S. Curtis’s great grandson, John Graybill, at our benefit reception on Friday and Saturday, February 14th and 15th from 5 to 9 pm. Drawing on our mutual admiration for Curtis’s works and desire to champion the descendants of his subjects, Valley Fine Art will donate proceeds to The Curtis Legacy Foundation. Guests at the reception will be able to view side-by-side examples of Curtis’s and Graybill’s photogravures featuring descendants born decades apart, with the story behind the pieces and Mr. Graybill on hand to share his personal account.
You will see:
“Red Cloud, Sioux, 1905” alongside Henry Red Cloud;
“Old Person, Piegan, 1911” alongside Reevis, “Mountain Chief;
and Piegan, 1911” alongside Peter Vandenberg.

About the Gallery
The incomparable collection of masterworks by Edward Curtis sets Valley Fine Art apart from all other galleries in the west. Mia Valley has earned recognition as one of the foremost experts in the ethnographic work by Edward Curtis, and she and her staff are frequently called upon to act as authorities on Edward Curtis’s work.

###
For further information, please contact Mia Valley at Valley Fine Art, (970) 920-9193.